March 9, 2018

How to Look After the Pennies…

Nick Saving Money 8 Comments

I was having a sort-out in the kitchen and came across a jar of small change. There were a few pounds’ worth, so I thought I’d change this into something more useful. It turned out to be a bit more complicated that I expected. So I thought I’d set out the options here and reveal what I did in the end, and what I plan to do with my small change from now on.

Banks

In the small town where I live there is now only one bank left (Barclays) and this is not a bank I have an account with. I went in there anyway to ask if they would accept change from me. I was told that if I didn’t have an account with them they wouldn’t be able to assist me.

So far, so disappointing. In these days of multiple bank closures, it’s a shame the banks can’t co-operate a bit more to help their local communities, but there we are.

So I had to travel a bit further to find a branch of HSBC, one of two banks I have accounts with. They kindly provided me with a supply of clear plastic coin bags. They are a standard design as far as I know and bear the following message:

£1 in 2p or 1p

£5 in 10p or 5p

£10 in 50p or 20p

£20 in £1 or £2 coin

NO MIXED COIN

I must admit I misunderstood this initially. I thought it meant you could have a £1 bag of mixed 1p and 2p coins, a £5 bag of 5p and 10p coins, and so on.

The nice lady at HSBC in Lichfield told me this wasn’t the case. The bag has to be all of the same denomination – so a £1 bag of 1p coins, a £5 bag of 10p coins, etc.

I do still think the instructions are a bit ambiguous, even if it does say NO MIXED COIN. Anyway, she kindly still accepted the bags I gave her and changed them for a note and some pound coins.

• I’ve heard it said that some banks have change machines that let you pay in coins and count them automatically, but I’ve yet to see this myself. If you have seen any with your own eyes, I’d be grateful if you could tell me where!

Coinstar Machines

This is the commercial alternative for dealing with your small change.

These machines are generally installed in supermarkets, including Tesco, Morrisons and Sainsbury. You just pour in your change and the machine automatically counts it and prints out a credit note to use in the store. You can either put this towards the cost of your shopping or redeem it for cash at the store’s customer services desk.

Of course, this service isn’t free. According to the Coinstar website, they charge a 9.9% processing fee for cash transactions “but fees may vary by location”. The fee is deducted from the amount you put in at the time of your transaction. You can also opt to donate your money to charity, in which case there is a lower 7% charge.

You can find the location of your nearest Coinstar machine by entering your postcode in the box at the top right of the Coinstar site. This doesn’t appear to be updated very often, though. It is still saying there is a machine in my local Morrisons, despite the fact that this was removed over a year ago (and didn’t work for some time before that).

Coinstar machines offer a quick and easy solution if there is one near you, but with the 10% charge (or thereabouts) you do pay a premium for the convenience.

My Advice

My advice then is to go to your bank and ask for a supply of clear plastic coin bags and fill them with coins of one denomination only. You can then either pay them into your account or change them for something more convenient.

As a result of my experiences, in my kitchen I now have a set of jars for coins of each type (pictured above) and periodically sort my small change into them. In due course I will count them and take them to the bank in coin bags (which I keep handy in the kitchen drawer).

You can, incidentally, also buy coin-sorting moneyboxes from Amazon (see below), but aside from the novelty value I’m not sure how useful or reliable these would prove!

Over time we all inevitably accumulate loose change, which can weigh down our pockets or purses and is easy to regard as a bit of a nuisance. This money adds up, though. Saving and sorting it really is worthwhile, and can provide a handy cash boost when you pay it in.

As ever, if you have any comments or questions about this post, please leave them below. And finally, for some additional ideas on saving money and making money with apps, check out this great post by my fellow money blogger Grainne on her Wannabe Debt Free blog.